» Plaine Commune » Traffic » Citizen proposal #2

i2: Ban of Motorized Scooters

Rejected (rank 3)

5	Yes	50%	Yes
2	No	20%	No
3	Abstention	30%	Abstention

Motorized scooters shall be banned from the walkways.

Reasons

Moving scooters endanger pedestrians.
Parked scooters obstruct the walkway and create a barrier, in particular for the elderly and disabled.

Suggestions

Only ban rental scooters: This is an interesting idea and I actually see the point. However, I will not adopt it for this initiative because a full ban should be a voting option. Please consider an alternative suggestion. -not adopted-

draft history (2)

Suggestions for improvement (1)

written and rated by the supporters of this initiative to improve the proposal and its reasons

Make an exception for individually owned scooters

by Andreas Nitsche

collective rating:

| implemented:

The vast majority of scooters obstructing the walkways are rentals. Individual owners usually store their equipment in a safe place and don't obstruct the walkway. Furthermore, they don't show such a tendency to careless driving.

Details

Citizen proposal #2

1. Admission (reached 1)

2. Discussion (finished)

3. Verification (reached 10.0% / 1)

4. Voting (finished)

Finished with winner

Competing initiatives

i4: Ban rental scooters, allow individually owned scooters
by Andreas Nitsche
Reached ≥50/100: 6 Yes (60%), 1 No (10%), 3 Abstention (30%)
Competing initiatives in pairwise comparison to winner:
i3: Test OLA
by Gregory Tsardanidis

What can I do here?

This issue is closed

Voters

Andreas Nitsche +1

Dimitris Kosmidis

Axel Kistner

Dominique

Jules Durant

Westbrook

Amity

Anne Roberts

Claretta

TRACE

System trace (for computer programmers purposes)

this: u=1.7, d=0.0, t=1.7 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=1.7, d=0.0, t=1.7 ms
Configuration "devel"
REQUESTED VIEW: initiative/show
this: u=2.7, d=3.0, t=5.4 | children: u=23.8, d=17.4, t=38.6 | total: u=26.5, d=20.4, t=44.0 ms
/main/_filter/20_session.lua
- SELECT "session".*, authority_uid FROM "session" WHERE (ident = 'GdUWwRp3349lI3Fb8Gn18JQx') LIMIT 1; 3.0 ms
- this: u=0.3, d=0.0, t=0.3 | children: u=23.5, d=17.4, t=38.3 | total: u=23.8, d=17.4, t=38.6 ms
  /main/_filter/21_auth.lua
  - No authentication needed.
  - this: u=0.5, d=0.0, t=0.5 | children: u=23.0, d=17.4, t=37.9 | total: u=23.5, d=17.4, t=38.3 ms
    /main/_filter_view/30_navigation.lua
    - this: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | children: u=22.9, d=17.4, t=37.8 | total: u=23.0, d=17.4, t=37.9 ms
      /main/_filter_view/34_stylesheet.lua
      - this: u=0.1, d=0.0, t=0.1 | children: u=22.8, d=17.4, t=37.7 | total: u=22.9, d=17.4, t=37.8 ms
        /main/_filter_view/36_html_title.lua
        this: u=3.5, d=4.5, t=7.4 | children: u=19.3, d=12.8, t=30.2 | total: u=22.8, d=17.4, t=37.7 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: initiative/show
        SELECT "initiative".* FROM "initiative" WHERE (id = 2) LIMIT 1; 1.4 ms
        SELECT "issue".*, justify_interval(min_admission_time)::text AS "min_admission_time_text", justify_interval(max_admission_time)::text AS "max_admission_time_text", justify_interval(discussion_time)::text AS "discussion_time_text", justify_interval(verification_time)::text AS "verification_time_text", justify_interval(voting_time)::text AS "voting_time_text", justify_interval(coalesce(issue.fully_frozen + issue.voting_time, issue.half_frozen + issue.verification_time, issue.accepted + issue.discussion_time, issue.created + issue.max_admission_time) - now()) AS "state_time_left", justify_interval(now() - issue.closed) AS "closed_ago" FROM "issue" WHERE ("issue"."id" IN (2)); 1.8 ms
        this: u=5.1, d=2.2, t=7.0 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=5.1, d=2.2, t=7.0 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: issue/_head
        SELECT "policy".*, justify_interval(min_admission_time)::text AS "min_admission_time_text", justify_interval(max_admission_time)::text AS "max_admission_time_text", justify_interval(discussion_time)::text AS "discussion_time_text", justify_interval(verification_time)::text AS "verification_time_text", justify_interval(voting_time)::text AS "voting_time_text" FROM "policy" WHERE ("policy"."id" IN (1)); 1.0 ms
        SELECT "area".* FROM "area" WHERE ("area"."id" IN (1)); 0.7 ms
        SELECT "unit".* FROM "unit" WHERE ("unit"."id" IN (1)); 0.6 ms
        this: u=0.9, d=1.8, t=2.5 | children: u=1.1, d=0.0, t=1.1 | total: u=1.9, d=1.8, t=3.5 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: initiative/_head
        SELECT "member".*, "initiator"."initiative_id" AS "mm_ref_", initiator.accepted AS "accepted" FROM "member" INNER JOIN "initiator" ON "initiator"."member_id" = "member"."id" WHERE ("initiator"."initiative_id" IN (2)) AND (initiator.accepted) ORDER BY member.name; 1.8 ms
        this: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.2 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.2 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: initiative/_bargraph
        this: u=0.9, d=0.0, t=0.9 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.9, d=0.0, t=0.9 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: initiative/_sidebar_state
        SELECT "draft".* FROM "draft" WHERE ("initiative_id" = 2) ORDER BY "id" DESC LIMIT 1; 0.8 ms
        SELECT "draft".* FROM "draft" WHERE ("initiative_id" = 2) ORDER BY "id" DESC LIMIT 1; 0.2 ms
        SELECT count(1) FROM (SELECT "draft".* FROM "draft" WHERE ("draft"."initiative_id" IN (2)) ORDER BY "id" DESC) AS "subquery" LIMIT 1; 0.3 ms
        this: u=2.5, d=1.8, t=4.0 | children: u=0.5, d=0.0, t=0.5 | total: u=3.0, d=1.8, t=4.5 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: initiative/_suggestions
        SELECT "suggestion".* FROM "suggestion" WHERE ("suggestion"."initiative_id" IN (2)) ORDER BY "proportional_order" NULLS LAST, id; 0.7 ms
        SELECT "opinion".* FROM "opinion" WHERE (member_id = NULL) AND (suggestion_id = 1) LIMIT 1; 0.3 ms
        SELECT "member".* FROM "member" WHERE ("member"."id" IN (1)); 0.3 ms
        this: u=0.5, d=0.0, t=0.5 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.5, d=0.0, t=0.5 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: suggestion/_collective_rating
        SELECT "rendered_suggestion".* FROM "rendered_suggestion" WHERE (suggestion_id = 1) AND (format = 'html') LIMIT 1; 0.4 ms
        this: u=0.5, d=0.0, t=0.5 | children: u=3.3, d=2.9, t=5.6 | total: u=3.8, d=2.9, t=6.1 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: issue/_sidebar
        this: u=0.7, d=0.0, t=0.7 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.7, d=0.0, t=0.7 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: issue/_sidebar_state
        this: u=0.5, d=0.7, t=1.1 | children: u=2.1, d=2.2, t=3.8 | total: u=2.6, d=2.9, t=4.9 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: issue/_sidebar_issue
        SELECT "initiative".* FROM "initiative" WHERE ("initiative"."issue_id" IN (2)) ORDER BY initiative.admitted DESC NULLS LAST, initiative.rank NULLS LAST, initiative.harmonic_weight DESC NULLS LAST, id; 0.7 ms
        this: u=0.3, d=0.0, t=0.3 | children: u=1.8, d=2.2, t=3.5 | total: u=2.1, d=2.2, t=3.8 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: initiative/_list
        this: u=0.8, d=0.9, t=1.5 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.8, d=0.9, t=1.5 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: initiative/_list_element
        SELECT "draft".* FROM "draft" WHERE ("initiative_id" = 4) ORDER BY "id" DESC LIMIT 1; 0.2 ms
        SELECT "member".*, "initiator"."initiative_id" AS "mm_ref_", initiator.accepted AS "accepted" FROM "member" INNER JOIN "initiator" ON "initiator"."member_id" = "member"."id" WHERE ("initiator"."initiative_id" IN (4)) AND (initiator.accepted) ORDER BY member.name; 0.6 ms
        this: u=0.6, d=0.8, t=1.1 | children: u=0.4, d=0.6, t=0.9 | total: u=1.0, d=1.3, t=2.0 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: initiative/_list_element
        SELECT "draft".* FROM "draft" WHERE ("initiative_id" = 3) ORDER BY "id" DESC LIMIT 1; 0.2 ms
        SELECT "member".*, "initiator"."initiative_id" AS "mm_ref_", initiator.accepted AS "accepted" FROM "member" INNER JOIN "initiator" ON "initiator"."member_id" = "member"."id" WHERE ("initiator"."initiative_id" IN (3)) AND (initiator.accepted) ORDER BY member.name; 0.5 ms
        this: u=0.4, d=0.6, t=0.9 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.4, d=0.6, t=0.9 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: initiative/_bargraph
        SELECT "battle".* FROM "battle" WHERE (winning_initiative_id = 4) AND (losing_initiative_id = 3) LIMIT 1; 0.4 ms
        SELECT "battle".* FROM "battle" WHERE (winning_initiative_id = 3) AND (losing_initiative_id = 4) LIMIT 1; 0.2 ms
        this: u=1.4, d=0.6, t=1.9 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=1.4, d=0.6, t=1.9 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: issue/_sidebar_whatcanido
        SELECT "member".*, "initiator"."initiative_id" AS "mm_ref_", initiator.accepted AS "accepted" FROM "member" INNER JOIN "initiator" ON "initiator"."member_id" = "member"."id" WHERE ("initiator"."initiative_id" IN (2)) AND (initiator.accepted) ORDER BY member.name; 0.6 ms
        this: u=0.3, d=0.0, t=0.3 | children: u=3.8, d=3.6, t=7.0 | total: u=4.0, d=3.6, t=7.3 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: issue/_sidebar_members
        this: u=1.8, d=3.6, t=5.0 | children: u=2.0, d=0.0, t=2.0 | total: u=3.8, d=3.6, t=7.0 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member/_list
        SELECT count(1) FROM (SELECT "member".*, direct_voter.ownweight AS "ownweight", direct_voter.weight AS "voter_weight", vote.grade, direct_voter.comment AS "voter_comment", member.id = ANY(_member_list__delegating_voter.delegate_member_ids) AS "in_delegation_chain" FROM "member" INNER JOIN issue ON issue.id = 2 INNER JOIN direct_voter ON direct_voter.issue_id = 2 AND direct_voter.member_id = member.id INNER JOIN vote ON vote.member_id = member.id AND vote.initiative_id = 2 LEFT OUTER JOIN delegating_voter AS "_member_list__delegating_voter" ON _member_list__delegating_voter.issue_id = issue.id AND _member_list__delegating_voter.member_id = NULL WHERE (member.activated NOTNULL)) AS "subquery" LIMIT 1; 2.0 ms
        SELECT "member".*, direct_voter.ownweight AS "ownweight", direct_voter.weight AS "voter_weight", vote.grade, direct_voter.comment AS "voter_comment", member.id = ANY(_member_list__delegating_voter.delegate_member_ids) AS "in_delegation_chain" FROM "member" INNER JOIN issue ON issue.id = 2 INNER JOIN direct_voter ON direct_voter.issue_id = 2 AND direct_voter.member_id = member.id INNER JOIN vote ON vote.member_id = member.id AND vote.initiative_id = 2 LEFT OUTER JOIN delegating_voter AS "_member_list__delegating_voter" ON _member_list__delegating_voter.issue_id = issue.id AND _member_list__delegating_voter.member_id = NULL WHERE (member.activated NOTNULL) LIMIT 100 OFFSET 0; 1.6 ms
        this: u=0.5, d=0.0, t=0.5 | children: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.2 | total: u=0.6, d=0.0, t=0.6 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member/_show_thumb
        this: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.2 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.2 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member_image/_show
        this: u=0.1, d=0.0, t=0.1 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.2 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member/_show_thumb
        this: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member_image/_show
        this: u=0.1, d=0.0, t=0.1 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.2 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member/_show_thumb
        this: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member_image/_show
        this: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.2 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.2 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member/_show_thumb
        this: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member_image/_show
        this: u=0.1, d=0.0, t=0.1 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.1 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member/_show_thumb
        this: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member_image/_show
        this: u=0.1, d=0.0, t=0.1 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.1, d=0.0, t=0.1 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member/_show_thumb
        this: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member_image/_show
        this: u=0.1, d=0.0, t=0.1 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.1, d=0.0, t=0.1 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member/_show_thumb
        this: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member_image/_show
        this: u=0.1, d=0.0, t=0.1 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.2 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member/_show_thumb
        this: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member_image/_show
        this: u=0.1, d=0.0, t=0.1 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.2, d=0.0, t=0.2 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member/_show_thumb
        this: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | children: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 | total: u=0.0, d=0.0, t=0.0 ms
        EXECUTE VIEW: member_image/_show
  - End of authentication filter.